You have an IGI certificate in front of you, or a seller tells you their stone is "IGI certified", and you do not know what to do with it. That is normal: most pages explaining these reports present them as a guarantee of quality. That is not what they are. A certificate describes a stone, it does not recommend it. Here is how to read it line by line, and above all what it will never tell you.
Contents
- What IGI is, and why it is IGI for lab grown diamonds
- The most important line on the report
- The four lines everyone looks at
- The line almost nobody looks at, and the one that matters most
- The case of coloured diamonds
- Checking a certificate in two minutes
- The five things a certificate does not say
- And when the stone is already set
- What to take away
- FAQ
What IGI is, and why it is IGI for lab grown diamonds
IGI, the International Gemological Institute, is an independent gemmological laboratory. It receives stones, analyses them, and publishes a report describing what it measured.
Independent is the key word. The laboratory neither buys nor sells stones. It has no interest in overrating yours.
In the lab grown diamond world, IGI became the reference laboratory by simple precedence: it started certifying these stones very early and systematically, while others were still hesitating over method. That is why the vast majority of lab grown diamonds on the market circulate with an IGI report.
A word on vocabulary, because it causes a lot of confusion. People say "certificate", but IGI publishes a "report". The nuance is not cosmetic: a certificate suggests an endorsement, a report states facts. It is a statement of fact.
The most important line on the report
If you look at only one thing, look at this one, and it is not among the 4Cs.
Find the line naming the type of stone. It appears at the top of the report, and it must say explicitly that this is a lab grown diamond. The standardised wording is laboratory grown diamond. The report also states the growth method when it has been identified: CVD or HPHT.
Why is this the most important line? Because it is the only one you cannot verify by any other means at home. A lab grown diamond and a mined diamond have the same composition, the same hardness, the same refractive index. The diamond testers sold online measure thermal conductivity: they say "this is a diamond", and they are right in both cases. They do not tell a lab grown stone from a mined one. Only an equipped laboratory can. We go into this in our article on how to identify a lab grown diamond.
Just below, note the report number. On most lab grown stones, that number is also laser engraved on the girdle, the rim of the stone. Invisible to the naked eye, readable with a loupe. That is what physically links the paper to the stone.
The four lines everyone looks at
The 4Cs, in the order they appear and with what to do about each.
Carat. This is a weight, not a size. One carat is 0.20 grams. Two one-carat stones can have very different diameters depending on their shape and depth. The report also gives the dimensions in millimetres: those are what tell you what you will see.
Colour. The scale runs from D, colourless, to Z, tinted. For a white diamond, D to F is colourless, G to J is near colourless. Beyond that, the yellow tint becomes noticeable. A practical point: in a yellow gold setting, a G looks as white as an E, because the metal warms the stone. Paying for a D to set it in yellow gold is money badly placed.
Clarity. From FL and IF, no inclusions, to I3, inclusions visible to the naked eye. The useful threshold is called eye clean: a stone whose inclusions cannot be seen with the naked eye at normal distance. VS1 and VS2 almost always are. VVS exists, costs more, and changes nothing about what you see.
Cut. Graded from Excellent to Poor. We come back to it immediately, because it is the decisive line.
To understand how these four criteria combine and where to put your budget, our diamond buying guide goes into detail.
The line almost nobody looks at, and the one that matters most
Here is our most useful piece of advice on a certificate: cut comes before colour and before clarity.
The reason is simple. Colour and clarity are characteristics of the rough stone. Cut is the only one of the four criteria that depends entirely on human work, and it is cut that decides whether light enters, bounces and comes back out towards your eye, or leaks out of the bottom.
A badly cut D VVS1 stone is dead. A perfectly cut G VS2 stone shines. And the second costs less than the first.
Watch out for one subtlety: an overall cut grade is only given on the round brilliant, because a numerical standard exists for that shape. On a pear, a marquise, an oval or an Asscher, the report grades only polish and symmetry, not overall cut. There is no universal standard for those shapes.
The direct consequence, and it matters: on any shape other than the round, the certificate cannot tell you whether the stone is beautiful. You have to see it. To choose the shape before even talking certificates, see our guide to which diamond shape to choose.
The case of coloured diamonds
If your stone is blue, green, pink or yellow, the report does not read the same way at all.
The D to Z scale no longer applies. It measures the absence of colour, which makes no sense for a stone whose colour is the point. The report switches to another grid, the one for so-called fancy colours.
Three elements replace the letter.
Hue. The dominant colour and its secondary notes. Word order counts: a greenish blue and a bluish green are not the same stone.
Intensity. This is the criterion that sets the price, and it is graded. The wording runs from faint and very light up to fancy vivid and fancy deep, passing through fancy light, fancy and fancy intense. One step up changes the stone and changes the price.
Distribution. The report states whether the colour is even. A stone whose colour concentrates in places presents less well.
Worth remembering: on a coloured stone, clarity moves to second place. Intensity masks a lot of inclusions, and it is the hue people look at. Paying for a VVS on a vivid blue diamond is a bad trade. Put that money into one more step of intensity.
Checking a certificate in two minutes
A PDF can be made up. A report number can be checked. Do these three things, in this order.
1. Note the report number. It is at the top of the document, and it is unique.
2. Enter it on the laboratory's website. IGI provides a public report verification tool. You enter the number, the laboratory displays what it recorded itself. If the values shown do not match your PDF, the website is not the problem.
3. Compare the engraving. Ask for a macro photo of the girdle, or have the number read with a loupe. It must match. That is the only physical link between the paper and the stone you are holding.
If a seller refuses steps 2 or 3, you have your answer. We gathered the other useful habits in our article on buying jewellery online safely.
The five things a certificate does not say
This is the part sales pages systematically leave out.
1. Whether the stone is beautiful. A report measures. It does not judge. Two stones with identical lines can produce very different results, especially on elongated shapes where no overall cut grade is given.
2. The bow tie effect. On a marquise, an oval or a pear, a dark band often crosses the centre of the stone. No report mentions it. You have to see the stone, in normal light, not in a studio.
3. How it behaves in real light. Measurements are made in controlled conditions. Your desk, a restaurant and daylight are not controlled conditions.
4. The quality of the piece of jewellery. This is the costliest blind spot. The report only covers the loose stone. It says nothing about the metal, the fineness of the gold, the strength of the claws or the care of the setting. A perfect stone badly set gets lost. The report does not protect you from that.
5. The fair price. A certificate is not a valuation. Two stones with identical lines can sell at very different prices depending on the seller, the setting and the margin.
In other words: a certificate protects you from being lied to about the stone, not from making a bad purchase.
And when the stone is already set
This is the most common case and the least well explained.
A full report is made on a loose stone. Once the stone is mounted, the laboratory can no longer measure certain things: exact proportions, actual weight, sometimes clarity under a claw.
So there are two situations.
The stone was certified before setting. This is how a serious workshop works. The report exists, it describes the loose stone, and the engraved number lets you make the link once the piece is finished. Ask for the report and the number, they must match.
The piece comes with an in-house document. A seller's own sheet is not a laboratory report. That is not necessarily dishonest, but it is not the same thing, and you need to know which of the two you have.
With us, every stone is an IGI certified lab grown diamond, certified before mounting, and the pieces are designed in Paris. If you want a specific stone, with its report chosen in advance, that is exactly what our bespoke service does.
What to take away
An IGI report states facts, it does not recommend. It is protection against being lied to, not a beauty label.
The first line to read is not one of the 4Cs: it is the words lab grown diamond, because that is the only information you cannot verify any other way. A diamond tester will not give it to you.
Within the 4Cs, put cut ahead of colour and clarity. Aim for an eye clean stone rather than a VVS, and a G to J colour if the setting is yellow gold.
On a coloured stone, read intensity, not clarity.
And remember what the paper ignores: the bow tie effect, the behaviour in real light and the quality of the setting. For those, you have to look at the piece.
FAQ
What is an IGI certificate?
It is an analysis report issued by the International Gemological Institute, an independent laboratory. It describes one specific stone: its type, its weight, its colour, its clarity and its cut. It states measurements, it gives no opinion on the quality of the piece or on its price.
How do you know from a certificate that a diamond is lab grown?
The statement appears at the top of the report and must be explicit. The standardised wording is laboratory grown diamond. The report often also states the growth method, CVD or HPHT.
Can a diamond tester identify a lab grown diamond?
No. These devices measure thermal conductivity and answer only "this is a diamond". Since a lab grown diamond has exactly the same composition as a mined one, the tester says yes in both cases. Only an equipped laboratory can tell them apart.
How do you verify an IGI report number?
Note the number at the top of the document, then enter it in the laboratory's public report verification tool. Then compare the values shown with your PDF, and have the number engraved on the stone's girdle read out.
Which criterion should you look at first on a diamond certificate?
After the statement of the type of stone, the cut. It is the only one of the four criteria that depends on human work, and it decides whether the stone shines. A well cut G VS2 shines more than a badly cut D VVS1, and it costs less.
Why do some shapes have no cut grade on the report?
Because a numerical cut standard only exists for the round brilliant. On a pear, a marquise, an oval or an Asscher, the report grades only polish and symmetry. On those shapes, the certificate cannot say whether the stone is beautiful.
How do you read a coloured diamond certificate?
The D to Z scale does not apply. The report gives the hue, the intensity and the distribution of the colour. Intensity is the criterion that sets the price: it is graded from very light up to fancy intense, fancy vivid and fancy deep.
Does a certificate guarantee the quality of the piece of jewellery?
No, and that is its most important blind spot. The report describes only the loose stone. It says nothing about the fineness of the gold, the strength of the claws or the care of the setting. A perfect stone badly set ends up getting lost.
Fiona