People pick a diamond shape for a ring by looking at their hand. For earrings, almost nobody asks the question: you take a round and stop thinking about it. That is a shame, because at the ear the rules change completely. Shapes that are a problem on a ring become obvious choices, and the reverse is true too. Here is how to choose.
Contents
- Why the shape is not chosen as it is for a ring
- The round brilliant: the default, and it is a good one
- The pear: the shape that points
- The marquise: finally in the right place
- Asscher and step cuts: the grown-up option
- Oval, cushion, and the case of hoops
- Weight, the subject nobody raises
- And if the stone is coloured
- The summary by use
- FAQ
Why the shape is not chosen as it is for a ring
Three differences, and they are enough to overturn every usual ranking.
An earring takes no knocks. A ring hits door handles, keyboards, bags. A stone at the ear meets nothing. That is the biggest gap of the three, and it changes everything for pointed shapes.
You never look at it face on. A ring is viewed from above, flat. An earring is seen at three quarters, in profile, from a distance. Flaws that only show face on matter far less.
There are two of them. A ring carries one stone. A pair carries two stones, which have to look alike. On some shapes that symmetry is easy. On others, it is the real issue.
If you are starting from scratch on the shapes themselves, begin with our overview of diamond shapes and cuts, then come back here.
The round brilliant: the default, and it is a good one
The round brilliant dominates the stud market, and for once the majority choice is the right one.
Three concrete reasons. It has no point, so no fragile angle. It has no orientation, so it cannot sit crooked when the post turns in the lobe. And symmetry between the two stones is easy to control, because a round looks like a round.
Its only real drawback is optical: at equal weight, a round shows less surface than an elongated stone. So it looks smaller. For the same money, you see less stone.
This is the choice to make if you want earrings you never take out, including to sleep and to swim. And it is the choice to make for a first pair.
The pear: the shape that points
The pear has one point and one rounded shoulder. On a ring, that point is its weak spot. At the ear, it becomes its argument.
What the pear does best: it creates a direction. Set point up, it opens the eye and lifts the line. Set point down, it lengthens and draws the eye towards the neck.
Both directions are valid, they just do not say the same thing. Point up is more graphic, point down is more classic. Try it in front of a mirror before deciding, the difference is obvious.
The trap with the pear is matching. A pear has an axis, and two pears must have exactly the same ratio and the same symmetry. A badly matched pair is spotted at once, because the two sides of a face are compared constantly. This is the one place where we insist on the selection more than on the stone itself.
The marquise: finally in the right place
The marquise is the shape worst served by the ring and best served by the ear. It is the sharpest reversal in this article.
On a ring, its two points concentrate knocks and catch on knitwear. We say so plainly in our article on the marquise cut diamond. At the ear, that problem disappears entirely. Nothing knocks into an earring.
Better still. On a ring, the marquise suffers from a flaw called the bow tie effect: a dark band crossing the stone widthways, visible mostly when you look at it face on. And an earring is almost never looked at face on. The flaw is still there, it simply becomes far less of a nuisance.
And like any elongated shape, the marquise shows more surface than a round at equal weight. At the ear you therefore get more visible effect for the same stone, without the risk.
If one shape deserved to be reserved for earrings, it would be this one.
Asscher and step cuts: the grown-up option
The Asscher is a square cut with clipped corners, with facets in steps rather than in triangles. Same family as the emerald cut.
These cuts do not sparkle, they reflect. People talk about a mirror effect or a hall of mirrors: large planes of light moving slowly instead of small quick flashes. At the ear, the result is calm and very clean.
The constraint is serious and we would rather say it: a step cut forgives nothing. Large flat facets hide no inclusion and no tint. An average stone passes unnoticed as a round brilliant, it shows in an Asscher. These stones are chosen one by one, which inevitably limits what is available.
This is the choice to make if you find the round brilliant too safe and the pear too demonstrative.
Oval, cushion, and the case of hoops
Two compromise shapes, worth knowing about.
The oval. It is the pear without the point and the round without the roundness. It lengthens a little, it has no fragile angle, and it matches more easily than a pear. Its bow tie is generally more discreet than a marquise's. It is the most balanced shape after the round.
The cushion. A square with rounded corners, cut in brilliant facets. It sparkles a great deal, in a broader and less needle-like way than a round. It sits very well in a discreet setting.
The case of hoops. As soon as the stone is no longer sitting on the lobe but set into a ring that turns, shape matters less and regularity matters more. On a hoop, small calibre round brilliants give the best result, because they send light back in every direction whatever the position of the hoop. An elongated shape on a hoop presents badly half the time.
Weight, the subject nobody raises
Here is the most practical advice in this article, and it has nothing to do with looks.
A stud rests on a lobe, which is soft tissue. Past a certain weight, the stud tips forward and the stone no longer presents properly. Over the years, the hole stretches.
Three consequences.
For daily wear, the modest stone well set beats the big stone. An elongated shape, which shows more surface for less weight, is a real advantage here.
The fitting matters as much as the stone. A properly calibrated push back, or a screw back on heavier pieces, improves comfort far more than another half carat.
And solid gold has an advantage that plating does not: the post in contact with the lobe does not wear through to reveal another metal. On vermeil, the gold layer eventually thins at exactly that point, which is the first place a stud wears.
And if the stone is coloured
Shape and colour are not two separate decisions, and that is even truer at the ear.
A coloured stone looks more intense when light travels through material. So a deep cut concentrates the colour and a spread cut dilutes it. Step cuts, Asscher and emerald, are the ones that show a tint best: large planes give a clear colour without chopping it into a thousand reflections.
The round brilliant does the opposite. It fragments the colour into flashes and gives a lighter impression than the stone actually is. That is not a flaw, it is a different effect.
One last point at the ear: colour is seen from a distance, not from twenty centimetres. Too delicate a tint disappears. If you want a colour to be noticed on earrings, take the bolder of the two options you are hesitating between. For the shades available and what they cost, see our guide to coloured diamond prices.
The summary by use
Every day, without thinking about it: round brilliant. No point, no orientation, no special care.
Maximum visible stone for the budget: marquise, then oval. Elongated shapes show more surface at equal weight.
Giving the face a direction: pear, point up to open, point down to lengthen.
A calm, clean look: Asscher or emerald, provided you accept a very clean stone and therefore a narrower choice.
Showing off a colour: step cuts, and a bold tint rather than a delicate one.
A hoop rather than a stud: small round brilliants, so the hoop reads well whatever its position.
And if nothing on this list matches exactly what you have in mind, that is precisely what our bespoke workshop is for.
What to take away
At the ear, a stone takes no knocks and is never looked at face on. Those two facts alone rehabilitate the marquise and the pear, both awkward on a ring.
The round brilliant remains the best default, and there is no shame in taking it. Elongated shapes give more visible surface for the same weight, which is a concrete argument and not a preference.
The real technical subject of a pair is not the stone, it is the matching of the two stones and the fitting. The two sides of a face are compared constantly, and a lobe copes badly with weight.
All our stones are IGI certified lab grown diamonds. To see the settings available, our lab grown diamond earrings are sorted by shape.
FAQ
Which diamond shape should you choose for earrings?
The round brilliant for daily wear with no constraints. The marquise or the oval to get the most visible surface at equal weight. The pear to give the face a direction. The Asscher for a calm look and to show off a colour.
Is a marquise better suited to a ring or to earrings?
To earrings, clearly. On a ring, its two points concentrate knocks and catch on knitwear. At the ear the stone meets nothing, and its bow tie effect becomes barely visible since you do not look at it face on.
Should a pear be worn point up or point down?
Both work. Point up opens the eye and gives a more graphic result. Point down lengthens and stays more classic. The difference is clearly visible in a mirror, so it is worth trying before choosing.
Why do two pear diamonds need to be matched?
Because a pear has an axis and a ratio. The two sides of a face are compared constantly, so any gap in proportion or symmetry between the two stones shows immediately. On a pair, selection matters as much as the stone.
What diamond weight should you choose for studs?
Less than people think. The lobe is soft tissue: past a certain weight, the stud tips forward and the hole stretches over the years. An elongated shape, which shows more surface for less weight, is a good way to gain effect without gaining weight.
What stone shape works for hoops?
Small round brilliants. On a ring that turns, regularity matters more than shape: a round sends light back whatever the position of the hoop, while an elongated stone presents badly half the time.
Which cut shows a coloured diamond best?
Step cuts, Asscher and emerald. Their large planes show the tint as one block, without fragmenting it. The round brilliant does the opposite: it chops the colour into flashes and gives a lighter impression than the stone is.
Does the fitting really matter?
Yes, and often more than the stone. A well calibrated push back, or a screw back on heavier pieces, improves daily comfort more than an extra half carat. And a solid gold post does not wear through to reveal another metal.
Fiona